JHyre wrote:Here I thought this might result in some useful conversation, but then you lapse into non-sequiturs. I would read the prior posts in this thread more closely and with a more open mind.
Yes. You should consider a poisonous sense of humor on my side as well.
JHyre wrote:First, an absolute "Commie Takeover With Guns In Your Face" is the least likely scenario.
Well, it seems you are nervous and think the sky is falling. (By the way, that's a myth that come from India).
JHyre wrote:The "Oh crap, I am Custer in MezoAmerica"
Custer? I don't know what has in common Custer with the Spanish conquerors. Custer was practising a genocide, and not collecting gold, as Spaniards did. The Spanish conqueror is the archetype of the greed for gold, that's all. Nope, that was just a practical example that if you want to run with money, you better run with papers rather than with gold, which is too heavy.
JHyre wrote:and "Oh crap, I'm a Nazi fleeing Goetterdaemmurung" scenarios
Nope, oh crap, diamonds is the best way to escape when the sky falls down on the top of our heads.
JHyre wrote:strike me as......unlikely and clearly not applicable to what we are discussing here. Even in extreme circumstances, well-hidden and unadvertised caches, domestic and foreign, can be discretely recovered at an appropriate time. Given Commie penchant for seizing persons, the absolute last place I would store value would be on my person.
True. Commie are a bit obsesive, isn't? They have been portaited as the source of all evil
JHyre wrote:More likely means of seizure, as alluded to in this thread: A much more subtle, less bloody and gradual seizure via taxes, regulation and devaluation. It's not as if a pattern does not already exist in this regard. In this case, gold serves well to preserve value, also sans the messiness of eating and, um, recovering it.
OK. OK. Gold is a good alternative and I agree.
JHyre wrote:I find it unlikely that I will pursued by thousands of atlatl-armed hostiles in a sudden flight. However, in that event, the store of value would be elsewhere and I would devote my carting capacity to ammo to feed some firearm. Here in the knuckle-dragging US, citizens have not given up their right to self-defense.
A truly unnecesary measure, given the fact that if the U.S. ever has a gorilla (leader of a military coup) citizens will be scare out and dominated with the simple tactic all gorilla has: terror. By murder, persecuting, torturing and spreading rumours.
JHyre wrote:You have an obsession with pre-Columbian cultures, not to mention an evidently idealized view of the same. You bring them up even when the examples are of little relevance.
Obsesion? That's general culture. I live in the Americas, you know, and as an "American" (in the real and broader sense of someone that lives in the Western Hemisphere) I have a
DUTY to know about pre-Columbian cultures, and all those anecdotes are something we learn at primary school.
You, as an American (In the U.S. sense) I bet know quite a bit about your own Amerindian cultures. And I bet you can give me a lesson about the influences of the Iroquois in the formation of the U.S., about the Mississippians cultures, about Sioux cosmology, etc. Come on, you aren't a clone of an European but an American, and you certainly are informed of the origins of your land. Well, it is the same here.
JHyre wrote:Doubtless, this passes for scholarship at universities, which is why academics are broadly and rightly held in such low esteem.
I am not an historian, but history fascinates me. If you find something wrong in what I said, please let me know. I am always willing to learn.