admin wrote:What really grabbed me was how naive his attempt was to explain the crisis, as if the housing market bubble burst simply because they had some bad luck in new housing starts.
From everything I've read, I gather that this bailout isn't because of subprime mortgages, it's about all the Credit Default Swaps (a form of derivatives) that these banks put around these mortgages, creating a whole new investment market.
For the past two years, people have said there was no way the recent subprime mortgages could be too bad. The percentage of recently issued subprime mortgages was a small percentage of the total market of outstanding mortgages. They thought the bottom of the market was a year ago. But, it was the CDSs that added leverage (and opacity), turning a moderate problem severe.
I don't understand why the government (if they can intervene in a market via a bailout) can't declare credit default swaps worthless and illegal. I guess one argument against that would be that it would cause everyone's books to be rebalanced. But, the story is, everyones' books are essentially fraudulent right now because there's no way to determine the value (or liability) of a CDS. That's why the Fed slashed interest rates Sept. through Jan. Banks weren't loaning each other money through their "overnight" service because nobody trusted anyone's stated bookkeeping. The Fed slashed interest rates to encourage them to borrow money from the Fed, and loan to each other. But, that didn't work either. Banks were afraid to borrow from the Fed's discount window because it is a public activity, and would lead to the belief they were unhealthy (when the fault was with the entire industry, and nobody would lend to anyone because nobody knew who's books were sound). The Fed had to resort to anonymous auctions of discounted money.
I can understand wanting to avoid the volatility of a pure "free market" correction. But, this bailout smells like we're salvaging derivatives and irresponsible business practices. I think the economy would do pretty well if we declared CDSs illegal, and then tookover all the banks that failed, taking over their non-CDS assets/liabilities, and auctioning them off to new participants.
Mark
There are 10 different kinds of people in the world. There are those who understand binary, and those who don't.