by Vicki and Greg Lansen on Tue May 13, 2008 5:05 am
If I may, a recent article on the Patagonia News website: I have comments below.......
The protests come as members of the opposition Independent Democratic Union (UDI) described the government's response to the tragedy as “insufficient.” They also criticized what they perceive as the lack of government effort to finish the Carretera Austral (Southern Highway), a rural roadway that, if constructed, would connect the towns near the eruption with the Region X city of Puerto Montt.
“All we hear about today is the ecological and environmental disaster and how the people and the animals are suffering,” said UDI Sen. Jaime Orpis. “Chile has not showed the political will power to address this issue.”
“According to Public Works Ministry data, the government plans to construct only 5 kilometers of this road, leaving 60 kilometers left to build,” said Orpis. “Given the tragedy that the people of Chaitén are facing, we need to prioritize infrastructure, but not just 5 kilometers of it. I think the Public Works Ministry's response has been insufficient.”
Former Public Works (MOP) Minister Eduardo Bitrán proposed that the Carretera Austral be built through the middle of Pumalín Park, the nature reserve created by U.S. philanthropist Douglas Tompkins. The Chaitén Volcano happens to lie within the park’s boundaries. Tompkins, who proposed an alternative coastal route for the road, has been fighting the proposal ever since (ST, April 28).
According to Sen. Orpis, Tompkins has “superimposed the interests of the environment over the interests of the people.”
More than 12,000 civilians, including a few dozen residents holed up in Chaitén and Santa Barbara, have been evacuated since the volcano eruption began. The Agriculture Ministry had also initiated plans to rescue most of the 40,000 cows, sheep, and other livestock in nearby towns.
The Region X Governor's Office, however, issued a decree preventing animal rights organizations from traveling to Chaitén to rescue the estimated 600 pets – mostly horses, dogs and cats – abandoned there. As of Sunday, local animal activists said they were preparing legal arguments to have the decision overturned (ST, May 12).
By Matt Malinowski (editorATsantiagotimes.cl)
A disclaimer from Vicki: I do not have a comprehensive grasp of Spanish, I am not a citizen of Chile, while it is my home and I have my RUN, RUT, and it is the only home I have. I do not speak for anyone but myself, and these are my observations solely.
First: The Austral Highway. Using the non-completion of the Austral Highway through Pumalin Park is political posturing. Had the road been already completed it would have made as much sense as a "gas-tax holdiay" in the US. Ridiculous! As I've said before, I haven't formed an opinion of the road yet, but I can surmise that had the road been built, the number of people and businesses affected would have been far greater, and the evacuations much more difficult. It is absolutely ridiculous for this to even be a discussion at this point in time.
Other issues in the article address the inability of the government to address water and supplemental animal feed. I have to tell you that I take great issue with most reporting now days. The cut and paste of major news networks, the failure to verify information is disgusting! Read one article, read them all. The Patagonia Times seems to have avoided this trap for the most part, however..... As for Futa....Water, while not running efficiently in the taps, is available in great quantities. Hay, supplemental animal feed is available. Electric is on, internet is on, trucks with food, and supplies are making their way here from Palena, and Argentina. Yes, supplemental animal feed needs to continue to come, and in greater bulk. The difficulty it seems is that if you aren't sensational in your reporting, you don't get the ratings, or "hits". Or the funds for relief. If you say, we are ok, then people don't respond. While Futa is doing ok, it is not okay.
Yes, things are inconvenient. The ash is a pain in the ass. But for the most part, I'd rather be here than anywhere else in a disaster. The locals may have other opinions, and I defer to them. Beware news that is nothing more than blocking and copying one uninformed report as fact. My family in the US was absolutely frantic that we we history as in Pompei! Things are not well here by a long shot, but Futa is alive, and if for no other reason than the incredible and indestructible will of the people of this area of Chle, it will be here, thriving for a long, long time.
Vicki